March 2021

*|MC:SUBJECT|*
Here's How We Made a Lasting Impact in March 2021
Subsidies Should End after Damaging Results
In the face of the devaluation and hyperinflation, the government opted for a subsidy program to help abate the impact on citizens. Since the program is financed using the central bank’s foreign exchange reserves, it helped slow down devaluation. LIMS points out that the scheme proved to be a failure after costing an average of $6 billion per year, as it did not prevent half the population from going under the poverty line. Furthermore, excessive smuggling and black-market activities denied people the planned support. 
With the central bank down to the required reserves, continued funding to the subsidy program is no longer an option. LIMS explained that the lifting of subsidies is necessary to stop the hemorrhaging of reserves and enabling an economic recovery plan. Previously subsidized products will rise in price, but most of those products are in short supply already. The smugglers and market monopolists will effectively fall out of favor, and shortages will become a less frequent occurrence. LIMS reiterated that supporting citizens out of the crisis can solely be done by solving its main concern, which is the currency depreciation. An instant relief program could be put in place the time the currency is stabilized. A Quasi Universal Basic Income (QUBI) would cost 6 times less than the current subsidies program and be more effective in helping the population in need. 
LIMS Media Interviews:
  • Lebanon Collapsing Into Despair, March 17, 2021: Aliwaa, Article AR
  • Reserves Almost Entirely Spent On Subsidies, What's The Solution To The Dollar Crisis, March 18, 2021: Sawt Kol Lobnan, Radio Interview AR
  • Cement Prices Up By 750%, March 18, 2021: Nidaa Al Watan, Article AR
  • Lifting Subsidies Will Not Impact The Exchange Rate As It’s Expected, March 19, 2021: Al Majalla, Article AR
  • FAO Warns Of Food Insecurity In Lebanon Amid Collapse In Lira Value, March 24, 2021: France 24, TV Interview AR
  • The Subsidy Program Was A Bad Policy That Worsened The Crisis, March 27, 2021: NBN, TV Interview AR
  • Consultation Meeting To Discuss The Remaining Solutions To Preserve The Rights Of Depositors, March 29, 2021: Al Markazia, Article AR
  • Covid-19 Worsened Lebanon’s Economic Crisis, March 15, 2021: Pharmaceutical Technology, Article EN
Electricity Subsidies Continues Draining Dollar Deposits
With fuel reserves running out by the end of March, the Ministry of Electricity turned to the Lebanese parliament asking for yet another treasury advance of 1,500 billion Lebanese pounds. If approved, the Ministry will use the subsides program to obtain US dollars from the central bank in exchange for the Lebanese pounds. By doing so, the ministry would be able to purchase fuel at 1/5th the market price (80% subsidy rate) and run power plants. However, should the request be declined, the ministry has threatened a countrywide blackout.
LIMS weighed in on the matter saying that the choice of either racking up more debt or living in complete darkness is unacceptable. In a time of crisis, the ministry is looking to appropriate the remaining central bank’s foreign exchange reserves to fund the same policies that resulted in $34 billion of losses in the past decade. Instead, the government entity should implement ways to cut spending and increase income. Electricity is too expensive because for years, the ministry has been bypassing the Tenders Department by signing illegitimate procurement contracts at an exorbitant cost through dubious bidding documents. Additionally, renting powerships has been an extremely expensive “temporary” solution, while the power plants are functioning at half capacity, due to a lack of funds to purchase fuel. Repatriating the powerships would free up enough funds, LIMS stated, that would improve the electricity coverage from 12 to 15 hours daily. 
While the ministry claims to want to switch the power plants to function on cheaper natural gas, LIMS believes this plan is outdated and ineffective. Around half the electricity supply is wasted on technical losses and uncollected bills. The other half is sold at a loss. Changing the fuel type will not resolve those two problems. 
LIMS noted that private generator owners have an almost 100% collection rate and they sell their electricity for profit. Yet, their generators have a high production cost and pollute. With the recent breakthroughs in lithium battery technologies, solar power seems to be the ideal solution for Lebanon’s electricity crisis. By licensing private power generators and incentivizing their switch to solar panels and storage batteries, multiple problems would be resolved. Pollution would be eliminated, invoice collection ensured, and the inherently decentralized solar grid fixes the technical losses in transmission. With 300 sunny days a year, a privatized solar power grid can turn Lebanon into a pioneering country in renewables and ensure a permanent solution to the electricity problem, while costing the government 0 dollars. If implemented, LIMS estimates the cost of electricity production would drop from 25 cents/kWh to about 5-9 cents/kWh.
LIMS Media Interviews:
  • Fuel Crisis Worsens In Lebanon, March 4, 2021: Al Hurra, TV Interview AR
  • Electricity In Lebanon, Power Outages Almost Reach 20 Hours A Day, March 5, 2021: Al Araby.com, TV Interview AR
  • Choice Between Debt Or Darkness Is Unacceptable, March 12, 2021: MTV, TV Interview AR
  • Understanding The Lebanese Electricity Issue, March 14, 2021: NBN, TV Interview AR
  • Roundup: Lebanese Experts Urge Immediate Reform In Electricity Sector, March 17, 2021: Xinhuanet, Article EN
  • Repatriating Powerships Improves Electricity Coverage, March 26, 2021: Sawt El Shaab, Radio Interview AR
  • Treasury Advance Or Darkness: The Ministry of Electricity’s Threat To The Lebanese State, March 30, 2021: Annahar TV, TV Interview AR
Lebanese Pound’s Depreciation Accelerates Amid Bank Recapitalization 
In March 2021, the exchange rate saw an alarming jump to 10,000 Lebanese pounds (LBP) to the dollar, accompanied by a wave of nationwide protests. LIMS attributed the March jump to the Central Bank’s Basic Circular No. 154 that demanded banks to (1) increase their deposits with corresponding banks by 3% and (2) to recapitalize. The circular’s purpose was to help Lebanese banks revive business through enhancing their liquidity abroad and to start the bank restructuring process, since the government estimates bank losses at $63 billion, three times their $21 billion capital. Commercial banks, who manage to meet the recapitalization requirements, will remain opened, while those who fail will be either sold, liquidated, or merged. 
LIMS explained that recapitalization was accomplished by using local assets including: (1) shareholders’ deposits that were in effect frozen due to the de facto capital controls, (2) shareholders’ real estate whose nominal value increased due to hyperinflation, and (3) re-evaluating banks’ real estate portfolio. However, to enhance their position at their corresponding counterparts, several local banks raised “fresh” dollars on the black market. Such a move made the demand for dollars spike and sucked liquidity out of the market. LIMS expects the LBP’s devaluation to persist, until the Banking Control Commission’s final report is published. 
LIMS reiterated that the LBP depreciation will persist, so long as the government does not undertake monetary reform and refuses to cut its expenditures. The continuous increase in local currency supply to finance public debt and deficit explains the general foreign exchange rate trend. Banks restructuring requires a completely integrated plan that would take into consideration the stability of the currency and importance of restoring growth.  A currency board would play this role and would pave the way for other crucial reforms to follow. LIMS also suggested allowing foreign banks to enter the Lebanese market, as a way to revitalize financial intermediation, and restore public trust. 
LIMS Media Interviews:
  • Dollar Rate Will Keep On Increasing, Bank Recapitalization Accelerated The Collapse, March 2, 2021: Sawt Kol Lobnan, Radio Interview AR
  • Managed Float In The Black Market Failed And Squandered Reserves, March 2, 2021: Al Jadeed, TV Interview AR
  • Lira Collapses Into Mayhem, March 2, 2021: Al Omah, Article AR 
  • Lira Collapse Proves The System’s Failure, Bank Recapitalization Made Things Worse, March 3, 2021: France 24, TV Interview AR
  • Rise In Poverty Due To A Terrible Monetary Policy That Caused The Lebanese Pound To Devaluate, March 3, 2021: Alyawm, TV Interview AR
  • LIMS President Explains The Soaring Exchange Rate, March 3, 2021: Sputnik, Article AR
  • Lebanese Citizens Enraged, As Dollar Exchange Rate Has No Roof, March 3, 2021: Rassif22, Article AR
  • The Dollar In The Black Market Exchanges At 10,000 LBP, Here Are The Reasons, March 3, 2021: Ahwal Media, Article AR
  • No Roof For The Dollar Exchange Rate Under A Managed Float, March 4, 2021: VDL, Radio Interview AR
  • Beirut Dialogue, Nabil Fahed, Patrick Mardini, Zouhair Berro, Fadi Abou Chacra, March 4, 2021: Radio Liban Libre, Radio Interview AR
  • Mardini : A Currency Board Is The Only Remaining Salvation, March 5, 2021: VDL, Radio Interview AR
  • Foreign Workforce Reconsiders, Lebanon No Longer Appealing, March 5, 2021: Independent Arabia, Article AR
  • Lebanon…The Fate Of Bank Deposits Is Blurred, March 5, 2021: Anadol Agency, Article AR
  • Banking Sector…What’s Next?, March 6, 2021: Alseyasa, Article AR
  • Lebanon… Economic Experts Explains The Reasons Behind The Currency’s Collapse, March 6, 2021: Akhbar Al An, Article AR
  • The Dollar Is Driving Lebanese Mad, And They Scream “Why?!”, March 7, 2021: Janoubia, Article AR
  • Confusion And Chaos In Lebanese Markets After A Historic Collapse Of The Pound, March 17, 2021: Independent Arabia, Article AR
  • Citizens Resort To Storing Cash Dollars In Their Houses Until Trust In Banks Is Restored, March 18, 2021: Spot Shot, TV Interview AR
  • Limiting Exchanges To The Banking Sector Cannot Work Before Restoring Trust, March 18, 2021: Sawt Beirut International, TV Interview AR
  • Is Lebanon Approaching An Official Floating Exchange Rate Following The Pound’s Collapse?, March 29, 2021: Anadol Agency, Article AR
  • Several Structural Factors Are Driving The Dollar Price Up, It's The Decrease In Price That Is Surprising: March 21, 2021, LBC, TV Interview AR
 Cracking Down on The Black Market is Counterproductive
With the depreciation of the Lebanese pound, online pricing platforms and mobile phone applications started informing the public of the black-market rate. Following the sudden surge in the exchange rate beyond 10,000 LBP to the dollar, officials have blamed such online resources for manipulating and destabilizing the national currency. Shortly after, a crackdown on such pricing systems took place to enforce control over the foreign exchange rate. 
LIMS refuted the “manipulation” claims and explained that devaluation is normal given the absence of reforms. LIMS insisted that devaluation will persist with or without online platforms, as long as Lebanon keeps on printing Lebanese pounds (LBP). Cracking down on online platforms is actually counterproductive and catastrophic, LIMS noted. It will obscure the market value of exchange rate and make potential sellers unwilling to part with their dollars fearing a possibly unfair rate. Similarly, prosecuting unlicensed money changers for allegedly underpricing the Lebanese pound will result in a shrinking dollar supply on the black market and consequently even more devaluation.

LIMS also warned that the resulting smaller black market will be more prone to manipulation as politically protected online platforms and black-market exchangers will have the monopoly. Even the central bank’s proposed exchange platform is bound to fail and will lead to the squandering of the small amount of remaining foreign reserves, if an artificially lower exchange rate is set. Only a cut on public spending and a halt to money printing can stabilize the exchange rate. LIMS urged for fundamental reforms to be enacted to tackle the root causes of the depreciation, rather than the ramifications. The continuous freefall of the LBP makes the currency lose its function as a unit of account. Consequently, Lebanese markets are moving towards a well-needed dollarization of prices, which can allow businesses to perform proper economic calculations and ensure continuity in times of hyperinflation. 
LIMS Media Interviews:
  • Cracking Down On The Black Market Will Be Counterproductive, March 9, 2021: Al Jadeed, TV Interview AR
  • Shutting Down Online Platforms Won’t Stop The Currency From Depreciating, March 9, 2021: Al Jadeed, TV Interview AR
  • The Lebanese Flee From The Lebanese Pound: LBP10,000/USD, March 9, 2021: Asas Media, Article AR
  • Will Prosecuting Money Changers And Shutting Down Platforms Lead To A Dollar Shortage?, March 10, 2021: OTV, TV Interview AR
  • Printing Money For A Stimulus Package Will Be Catastrophic, March 11, 2021: Al Jadeed, TV Interview AR
  • Is Lebanon Approaching The Venezuelan Scenario Of Economic Crisis And Inflation?, March 11, 2021: Alyawm, TV Interview AR
  • Lebanon Is Boiling As Mobile Applications Drive The Pound To Collapse, March 13, 2021: Akhbar Al An, Article AR
  • Terrifying Tour In Supermarkets, Dollar Spike Drives Prices Through The Roof, March 13, 2021: Annahar, Article AR
  • Problems And Solutions, March 15, 2021: Tele Liban, TV Interview AR
  • No Ceiling For The Dollar Exchange Rate, Lebanon Nearing A Scenario Worse Than Venezuela, March 16, 2021: Tayyar.org, Article AR
  • Soon…New Marks Of The Great Collapse In Lebanon, March 17, 2021: Spot Shot, TV Interview AR
  • Dollar Price Out Of Control, Worst Is Still To Come, March 17, 2021: Asharq Al Awsat, Article AR
  • No Bottom To The Collapse Of The Lebanese Pound, Central Bank Platform Will Be Useless, March 24, 2021: Al Araby Al Jadeed, Article AR
  • The Central Bank’s Wrong Choices, March 27, 2021: Lebanon Economy Files, Article AR
  • Dollar Exchange Rate Will Continue To Rise, Platform Can Only Limit The Volatility, March 27, 2021, Radio Interview AR
  • Central Bank Platform Not A Solution, Dollar Price To Soar Again, March 25, 2021, Janoubia, Article AR
Only a Currency Board Can Save Lebanon Now
Lebanon have been experimenting with a managed float for over a year now. The rate is floating on the black market while the central bank has been interfering by injecting dollars via the subsidy program, in an attempt to manage the float. The managed float failed to stabilize the exchange rate, as perpetual depreciation has become a far too common occurrence.
LIMS explained that Lebanon does not have the proper institutional framework to protect the central bank from government interference. A currency board solves the problem by replacing the discretionary monetary policy of the central bank with a transparent rule-based monetary arrangement. More importantly, a currency board does not permit the issuance of unbacked banknotes. With the Lebanese pound (LBP) anchored to a foreign currency (the US dollar), the exchange rate can be fixed in as little as 30 days, crushing inflation and allowing an economic restart.
Establishing a currency board would also allow Lebanon to take advantage of arbitrage opportunities. According to LIMS, the LBP interest rate would be lowered, but remain slightly higher than its USD counterpart, as interest rates incorporate country risk, among other factors. Therefore, investors would be interested in taking advantage of the higher interest rates by depositing their dollars in Lebanon and exchanging them for LBPs. This time around the LBP would be fully backed by the dollar, creating stability for the LBP. The inflow of foreign capital would allow banks to restart their banking activities which would help them reduce their losses and stimulate the economy. 
LIMS urged the parliament to take the initiative by amending the Lebanese Code of Money and Credit and establishing a currency board. Such moves would put Lebanon back on the right track before the damage is irreversible. 
LIMS Media Interviews:
  • Currency Board For Lebanon, March 2, 2021: Executive Magazine, Article EN
  • Currency Boards Or Central Banks, March 3, 2021: Executive Magazine, Article EN
  • Where Is The Dollar Exchange Rate Heading Locally And Globally, March 4, 2021: Annahar TV, TV Interview EN
  • A Currency Board Is Lebanon’s Last Hope To Halt The Collapse Of The Pound, March 13, 2021: OTV, TV Interview AR
  • No Horizon To The Collapse, No Ceiling To The Exchange Rate, Currency Board Is The Only Solution, March 17, 2021: Al Jadeed, TV Interview AR
  • Lowering The Dollar Price Is Possible!, March 18, 2021: Lebanon 24, Article AR
  • People's Liras Becoming Worthless… The Solution Is A Currency Board, March 19, 2021: Lebanon 24, Article AR
  • To Currency Board Opponents: Stop Shielding The Corrupt With People's Livelihood, March 22, 2021: Annahar, Article AR
  • Lebanon’s Last Hope If A Government Is Not Formed, March 25, 2021: Lebanon Economy Files, Article AR
  • A Currency Board - Lebanon's Long Awaited Solution, March 11, 2021: Jbeil Daily News, Article AR
Metal Coins Vanishing From the Market
In March 2021, the LBP reached an all-time low, trading at 15,000 LBP to the US dollar. A peculiar phenomenon was noticed on the market, as metal coins became extremely scarce and almost nonexistent. LIMS pointed out that due to the incessant currency depreciation, the face value of the coins became lower than the value of the metal. In fact, the 250 LBP coin consisting of 5 grams of copper, aluminum and zinc, and the 500 LBP coin consisting of 6 grams of nickel and steel, now cost more than double their face value to be minted. Although technically illegal, hoarding metal coins, melting and reselling them as metal will become a more common practice if the freefall of the currency continues. LIMS warned that legal prosecutions cannot expect to control this practice. Only a sound monetary policy that slams the brakes on the LBP’s devaluation can restore value and trust in the national currency.
LIMS Media Interviews:
  • Metal Coins Became More Valuable Than Their Face Value, March 21, 2021: Al Sharq Al Awsat, Article AR
  • Is This The Farewell Of The 250 And 500 LBP Coins?, March 22, 2021: Spot Shot, TV Interview AR
Like our page Like our page
Check our website Check our website
Follow us Follow us
Copyright © 2021 Lebanese Institute for Market Studies - LIMS
contact@limslb.com - www.limslb.com
Call us +961 6 409305

 






This email was sent to *|EMAIL|*
why did I get this?    unsubscribe from this list    update subscription preferences
*|LIST:ADDRESSLINE|*

*|REWARDS|*