January 2021

*|MC:SUBJECT|*
Here's How We Made a Lasting Impact in January 2021
Two Official Meetings Organized by Parliamentary Committee to Discuss the Currency Board Option
The national Economy, Trade, Industry, and Planning Committee at the Lebanese parliament organized two official meetings on January 20 and 22 to listen to a proposal of setting up a currency board in Lebanon. The committee heard from Dr. Patrick Mardini, CEO of LIMS at the first meeting, and Professor Steve Hanke, the number one expert on currency boards worldwide at the second meeting. 

Dr. Mardini showed that Lebanon currently has enough reserves to establish a currency board at a very reasonable exchange rate. He then presented examples from Argentina, Bosnia, Bulgaria, Estonia, and Lithuania, showing how currency boards crushed hyperinflation, stopped currency devaluation, increased foreign exchange reserves, stimulated growth, and reestablished fiscal balance. In the second meeting Professor Hanke recommended that Lebanon follow Singapore’s example of economic transformation. He stressed on the importance of monetary stability and showed how it can restore the public’s trust and open the door for additional reforms. He further explained that establishing a currency board in Lebanon does not require any pre-condition and demonstrated how it can solve the problems of external imbalance and fiscal deficit. 
Some MPs had concerns about the balance of payment deficit, leading to the loss of foreign exchange reserves. They believed that the country must be able to produce more in order to reduce trade deficit and external imbalances as a pre-condition to any other reform. Other MPs were concerned with the governance of a currency board, the financing of fiscal deficit, and the impact on growth. Several MPs endorsed establishing a currency board in Lebanon and recommended appointing Prof. Hanke as advisor to the parliament to profit from his experience in the field, especially that professor Hanke is willing to offer his services pro-bono.  
The two meetings received good media coverage, with the first reported by 13 media outlets and the second by 15. 

1st Meeting Media Exposure: 
MTV, VDL News, Leb Economy Files, NNA, Elnashra, Almarkazia, Alkhabar Agency, Al Binaa, Tayyar.org, Klyoum, Lebanon Files, Addiyar, Nabd

2nd Meeting Media Exposure: 
Lebanon 24, Almodon, Private Magazine, Headlines Mania, Nabd, Annahar, Union of Arab Banks, NNA, Aljoumhouria, Eliktisad, Tayyar.org, Elnashra, VDL News, LBC, Lebanon Debate. 
Currency Board: A Major Topic of Discussion in Lebanese Media 
Prof. Hanke’s proposal on establishing a currency board in Lebanon to crush inflation in just one month stirred up a lot of controversy. In a series of TV, radio, and newspaper interviews, LIMS took a stand in favor of the proposal and elaborated on the working principles of a currency board and its key importance in defeating the crisis. 
LIMS explained that a currency board ends the discretionary monetary policy of the Central Bank and imposes strict rules on the issuance of banknotes. Those rules will restore trust in the Lebanese pound (LBP) and make it a clone of US dollar given that the local currency will be 100% backed by dollars. Additionally, the currency board would reduce the high currency risk, hence  attracting foreign investments capable of relaunching the stagnating economy. Therefore, this reform would tackle the three main factors that have been feeding hyperinflation: the lack of trust in the national currency, the excessive issuance of banknotes, and the negative economic growth. 
The impact of a currency board will not be limited to monetary stability as the substantial reduction in  currency risk would attract capital transfers back to Lebanon. These inflows would profit from the high return offered by the discounted assets and interest rate arbitrage. Capital inflows to Lebanon will therefore help relaunch the economy, increase foreign exchange reserves and reduce fiscal deficit. 
The currency board is not a magic pill that would resolve all Lebanon’s problems. For instance, banks will still have to deal with their “old dollar” problem. However, monetary stability and capital inflows will substantially reduce the problem of “old dollars”. Banks will be able to return to the business of financial intermediation, the time public authorities reach a final settlement with Eurobond holders and decide the way they wish to deal with “old dollars”. Banks are already distinguishing between “old dollars” which remain frozen and “fresh dollars” which profit from a freedom of movement.
While critics are promoting a “Managed Float Arrangement”, LIMS warned that the exchange rate of LBP will drown rather than stay afloat. In a country with weak institutions where the Central Bank prints money to monetize debt, a managed float will lead to further currency devaluation, indefinite capital controls, and squandering of the remaining foreign reserves. At present, Lebanon is experiencing a managed float. The local currency is floating on black market rate and the Central Bank intervenes via the subsidy program. Yet inflation has persisted, and the currency is far from stabilizing. 
LIMS Media Interviews: 
  • What Are The Only 5 Currencies That Devalued More Than The Argentine Peso in 2020, January 1, 2021: Explica.co, Article EN 
  • MP Alameh Regarding The Currency Board: It’s Our Job To Consider New Ideas To Get Out Of The Crisis, January 5, 2021: Elnashra, Article AR 
  • Mardini: Lebanon Has Enough Foreign Reserves To Adopt A Currency Board, January 6, 2021: NBN, TV Interview AR 
  • A Currency Board Solves The Lira Crisis And Restores Trust In The National Currency, January 6, 2021: RLL, Radio Interview AR 
  • Currency Board Between Approval And Rejection, Is It Really A Solution To The Lira, January 8, 2021: Annahar, Article AR 
  • The Lira Will Not Float, It Will Drown. The Solution Is A Currency Board, Not A Currency Float, January 8, 2021: OTV, TV Interview AR 
  • Economic Discussion of The Currency Board, January 8, 2021: Al Binaa, Article AR 
  • Impact of A Currency Board On Price Inflation, January 12, 2021: VDL, Radio Interview AR 
  • Will The Lebanese Reclaim Their Money That Was Confiscated By The Banks, January 15, 2021: Arab Majalla, Article AR 
  • Hariri Goes To Istanbul: Lebanon Tests Turkish Waters, January 16, 2021: Ahram Online, Article EN 
  • Hanke’s Inflation Dashboard: Official Statistics Misrepresent Real Inflation Rates, January 19, 2021: Cato Institute, Article EN 
  • Is The Adoption Of A Currency Board The Last Hope To Save The Economy, January 21, 2021: Ahwal Media, Article AR 
  • Parliament To Decide Now, The Currency Crisis Can Be Resolved In Just One Month, January 25, 2021: Eliktisad, Article AR 
Currency Devaluation Fueling the Population’s Pain
The local population is enduring the worst economic catastrophe the country has ever experienced. The national currency has continued its free fall, reaching an exchange rate of LBP 8,800 to the dollar and has been constantly losing value. LIMS explained that since the majority of the Lebanese population make their income in LBP, the devaluation of the currency coupled with hyperinflation is impoverishing everyone.  Lebanon’s GDP is expected to drop from $53 billion in 2019 to a meager $18 billion in 2020 due to the combination of a sharp devaluation and a severe economic recession. 
LIMS attributed the currency depreciation to the monetization of the debt and the loss of trust in the Central Bank’s ability to manage the currency. Prior to the crisis, the Central Bank’s primary focus was to lend the government money to finance ever-growing public expenditures and today this debt is serviced by growing money supply. The process of financing debt with money supply is expected to continue in 2021 since the government estimates a fiscal deficit of LBP 5.6 Trillion.

In the past, increasing money supply while maintaining a peg led to the overvaluation of the LBP and the loss of $40 billion on the Central Bank’s balance sheets, $20 billion of which was between 2018 and 2020. Today, growing money supply is responsible for the devaluation of the Lebanese pound and the hyperinflation. 
LIMS Media Interviews: 
  • Facing Its Worst Recession To Date, How Can Lebanon Solve Its Economic Crisis, January 3, 2021: El Estiklal, Article AR 
  • Lebanon Teeters On The Brink Of Collapse, January 14, 2021: Khaleej Times, Article EN 
  • Expert Predicts Further Lira Devaluation, January 25, 2021: Lebanon 24, Article AR 
  • What Will Happen To Exchange Rate In The Absence Of A Government. How Can A Currency Board Solve The Crisis, January 25, 2021: OTV, TV Interview AR 
  • Inflation Cannot Stop Unless The State Rectifies Its Practices, January 28, 2021: RLL, Radio Interview AR 
  • 2021 Budget Is Blind, January 28, 2021: Nidaa Al Watan, Article AR 
Who Will Pay the Political Cost of Cutting Subsidies?
Facing severe economic recession and hyperinflation, the government’s sole response was to put in place a subsidy program, covering medicine, fuel, and some 300 other products. LIMS has been explaining that subsidies are counterproductive and has led to large-scale smuggling and squandering of the remaining dollar deposits seized by the central bank. The success of this campaign on one hand, and the dwindling usable reserves on the other, made the subsidies program hard to maintain. However, lifting subsidies is politically unpopular as it will lead to an increase in the price of gasoline, food, and medicine. The caretaker government attempted to pass the hot potato to parliament, but the latter sent it back, insisting that it is the duty of the government to perform this task.  
As a solution to the deadlock, LIMS advocated replacing the subsidy program with cash transfers. LIMS has assisted the Ministry of Economy and Trade in designing a quasi-universal basic income (quasi-UBI) program that would cost 80% less than the current subsidies program. Unlike current subsidies, the quasi-UBI program would effectively alleviate the weight of the economic crisis, while saving around 10 Billion US dollars over the next 5 years. Alternatively, a direct cash transfer program to the most impoverished families would also provide a cost-efficient solution. 

LIMS Media Interviews:
●    Urgency To Reform Subsidies Disappears, As The State Continues To Evade The Problem, January 6, 2021: Ahwal Media, Article AR 
COVID Lockdowns Resulting in Violent Protests
Following a spike in COVID cases after the New Year’s holiday, the state enforced a new total lockdown in an attempt to reign in the spread of the virus. A short while later, nationwide protests erupted against the lockdown. LIMS pointed out that the government-imposed closure comes at a time of harsh economic recession where people have no access to their life savings withheld by the banks, and unable to earn a living in a constantly shrinking economy. Many people live on an income they earn on a day to day basis. The lockdown prevents those people from putting food on the table and they are therefore protesting. Given the current monetary and fiscal imbalances, the state stands incapacitated and unable to offer direct support to struggling families and businesses.
LIMS urged the Lebanese government to use a plethora of costless ways to help the economy weather the global coronavirus outbreak. The state can offer tax and tariffs exemptions which would substantially reduce the cost of living and help maintain some businesses afloat. Additionally, encouraging individuals to work from home is achievable by improving the internet connection and telecom networks. Such developments are only possible through repealing the telecom monopolies and opening the market to competition. If technological infrastructure improves, firms can then adapt to lockdowns and social distancing more effectively. 

On the healthcare side, LIMS encouraged the government to rely more on the private sector. Major deregulation in the healthcare industry should happen swiftly to allow the provision of additional ICUs and clinical service areas for COVID patients, opening field hospitals, and properly allocating in-kind donations. 

LIMS Media Interviews: 
  • A Lockdown Without Exemptions Is A Liquidation Of The Economy, January 24, 2021: Janoubia, Article AR 
  • Protests In Lebanon Against Deteriorating Economic Conditions, January 25, 2021: Al Omah, Article AR 
  • Protests Erupt Again As People Are Driven To The Brink Of Starvation, January 26, 2021: Annahar, Article AR 
  • Protester In Lebanon Clash With Police Over Bad Economic Conditions, January 28, 2021: Al-Jazeera, TV Interview EN 
Like our page Like our page
Follow us Follow us
Check our website Check our website
Follow us Follow us
Copyright © 2020 Lebanese Institute for Market Studies - LIMS
info@limslb.com - www.limslb.com
Call us +961 6 409305

 






This email was sent to *|EMAIL|*
why did I get this?    unsubscribe from this list    update subscription preferences
*|LIST:ADDRESSLINE|*

*|REWARDS|*