|
|
Participants engaged in the YALA Program delivered an outstanding advocacy campaign to address the barriers preventing tourism in Tripoli namely: the lack of security, cleanliness, and accommodation. The campaign started on social media and built a grassroot momentum highlighting how Tripoli suffers, such as through distortion, defamation, and inequality. Participants produced a short 26 second video that reached 38,886 people, 43,086 plays, 1,113 likes and 671 shares on Instagram. The video was also shared on Facebook and 71 stories were created on Instagram related to the campaign. The hashtag they created: Ahla Bhal Talleh in Tripoli “اهلا_بهالطلة_بطرابلس#” trended on Twitter, being among the top five.
|
|
Social media momentum attracted the attention of Tripoli’s members of parliament (MPs) that attended a rally, organized by the campaign team at Rachid Karami International Fair. Participants communicated the campaign’s demands during the rally and asked MPs to: (1) work with the Ministry of Interior and Municipalities to strengthen security in the city of Tripoli, (2) work with the local authorities to clean the city, especially the old souks and historical places, and (3) work with relevant ministries to find a solution for the Quality-Inn Hotel. Two MPs attended the rally in person, three MPs sent their representatives, and one MP invited participants to a meeting at his office. 21 newspapers and news-websites and 15 social media pages active in Tripoli covered the rally. Participants decided to form a smaller committee in charge of the follow up.
|
|
|
2022 Budget 8 Months Late, Falls Below Expectations
|
|
|
Parliament’s Finance and Budget Committee finished discussing the 2022 annual budget. The committee asked the Ministry of Finance for some clarification, especially on the exchange rate used for custom duties, commonly called the “customs dollar”. Pundits argued that the “customs dollar” should be set at 20,000 LBP to the dollar, while others suggested 12,000 or 14,000 LBP. Currently, the “customs dollar” rate is 1,500 LBP to the dollar, the central bank’s Sayrafa platform rate is around 26,000 LBP to the dollar, and the black-market rate is around 33,000 LBP.
|
|
|
LIMS believes that the budget is overly optimistic regarding expected revenues resulting from the increase in taxes, fees, and the customs dollar (tariffs). First, the year 2022 is almost over, and therefore new tariffs and taxes will only apply to the remaining four months of the year. Second, increasing the customs duties using the “customs dollar” will not lead to the projected revenues, since customs evasion would be incentivized. Many businesses would simply evade tariffs due to the large loopholes in the multi-rate system imposed, along with the corruption in the customs department. Tariff evasion is quite easy in Lebanon and businesses will either resort to it or shut down. Smugglers would also benefit from the increased tariffs at the expense of honest and legal businesses, and Lebanon would see a price hike for many goods. Third, increasing tariffs in a time of extreme crisis and poverty, would further stifle the market and intensify the crisis, while the actual government revenues would fall well below the anticipated amount.
LIMS opposed adding a new exchange rate dedicated to tariffs and suggested using the floating central bank’s Sayrafa platform rate. At the same time, LIMS suggested the simplification and reduction of tariffs substantially through using a unified flat rate on all imported items somewhere between 0% and 2%. Consequently, the increase in the “customs dollar” would be offset by the decrease in tariffs. Reforming customs in this way would positively impact consumers, while simultaneously rendering tariff evasion less tempting, in turn increasing the overall revenues.
|
|
Currency Crisis Still Plagues Lebanon’s Economy
|
|
|
The Lebanese pound (LBP) continues to devalue and dropped from 30,000 LBP to the dollar at the beginning of August to 34,000 LBP to the dollar by the month’s end. Looking back at the first half of 2019, the Lebanese pound was around 1,500 LBP to the dollar and stayed at a predictable rate.
|
|
|
LIMS stated that the number one reason for poverty in Lebanon is due to the LBP’s devaluation. In most of the country, people get their salary paid in the local currency, while the market prices are shifting toward unofficial dollarization. LIMS argued for a full and official dollarization that would enable businesses to price in dollars. After being allowed to price in dollars, businesses would be able to dollarize salaries, thus protecting the remaining purchasing power of their employees. Only then, taxes and tariffs can be dollarized. And the central bank can buy back all the LBPs in deposits and in circulation. From this perspective, the “customs dollars” are misplaced since the government is asking businesses to dollarize their customs’ payment, while imposing on them to price in LBP. Alternatively, Lebanon could adopt a currency board that would clone the LBP to the USD, so to speak, meaning that the entire money supply in LBP would be 100% covered by the reserve currency. Having a currency board in place would allow for LBP and dollars to be simultaneously in circulation.
|
|
Fuel Subsidies Shrinking but Not Obsolete Yet
|
|
|
Banque du Liban (Lebanon’s central bank, also called BdL) declared it would reduce fuel subsidizes. In fact, BdL supplied dollars to fuel importers through its Sayrafa exchange platform for 26,000 LBP to the dollar compared to 33,000 LBP to the dollar on the black market. This multiple exchange rate scheme provides a 20% subsidy to fuel importers.
|
|
|
LIMS views the central bank’s announcement as a beneficial step and should have happened a long time ago. The institute also called for subsidies to be stopped entirely. As long as the subsidy program is active, the central bank’s foreign reserves will continue being siphoned. Those reserves are actually what remains of dollar denominated deposits placed by people at commercial banks. In reality, those commercial banks deposited the funds at the central bank. Thus, the continuous squandering of such deposits is making financial solutions related to bank depositors much more difficult.
Due to importers having to buy their dollars from the black market, the public wonders about the likelihood of a further Lebanese pound (LBP) devaluation. LIMS explained that as long as the money supply is constant, the lifting of subsidies will not impact the exchange rate. For illustration, without more LBPs in the market, the demand for dollars will not spike, but only shift to essential products, such as gas. However, the continuous increase in the money supply will, regardless of subsidies, up the demand of foreign currency, thus devaluing the LBP.
|
|
Ukraine War Still Putting Strain on Food Prices
|
|
|
Wheat prices in Lebanon have been soaring amid an ongoing economic crisis. This is just one way the war on Ukraine has had a brutal impact on the Lebanese market. Unfortunately, government officials in Lebanon have resorted to subsiding wheat as a quick-fix solution. LIMS explains that subsidies are not the answer to residents being unable to afford some goods. Moreover, LIMS clarified that funding dedicated to subsidies will be misused, as incentives are tied to these programs. For instance, subsidized goods could be resold for higher prices in the international market or in the local black market. Still, it would be much more efficient to directly help Lebanese consumers through cash cards and preferably by implementing economic reforms, rather than subsidizing goods.
|
|
|
LIMS Media Interviews:
-
Ships Leaving Ukraine Good For International Markets: Analyst, August 1, 2022: Al Jazeera, Article EN
-
Graining Ground: Six Months Of Conflict In Ukraine, August 26, 2022: The New Arab, Radio Interview EN
|
|
Blackouts Are Back and Become Norm in Lebanon
|
|
|
For over two decades, Lebanon’s electricity sector has been in dire straits. Now though, with an unsettling economic crisis, obtaining and maintaining energy has become a no-win situation for residents and businesses alike. Although the government-owned power company Electricite du Liban (EDL) has had a monopoly over the sector, EDL has been incapable of providing 24-hour electricity. To provide a clearer picture, EDL-generated electricity averages about two hours per day across the country. Despite Law 129 being passed in 2019 asking the government to allow the private sector to build and operate electricity facilities, the government failed to grant any licenses.
|
|
With questions over the future involvement of the private sector, LIMS explained that the main issue is EDL’s monopoly. What is required today is not the transfer of the public monopoly to the private monopoly, but the liberation of the sector in its entirety. LIMS sees that the only path towards 24/7 electricity is the legalization of independent private investments in the sector, which means legalizing private power generation companies, as well as private electricity distribution companies (EDCs). Consumers would then have real options. Constant power outages would be a thing of the past, as residents would no longer have to depend on EDL’s energy supply.
|
|
|
LIMS Media Interviews:
- Solving Electricity Dilemma: By Privatization Or Liberalizing The Market? August 13, 2022: Lebanon 24, Article AR
|
|
|
|
|
|
|